An Excalibur 21 "New-in-Box" popped up on eBay and I jumped on it. It arrived and I have finally had a chance to use it. My "like new" Hawk Ultra VS 26 will be going up on Craigslist as soon as I take a break from using the Ex-21.
The Pros:
The reduction in vibration is massive. Even at max speed, the Ex-21 produces a lower level of vibration than my Hawk. This directly impacts accuracy and even operator fatigue.
Top-feed: My back is thanking me for the top-feed feature. The advantages to top-feed are probably, in part, a personal preference issue. I must say, I do not miss the pretzel posture needed for bottom feed and the speed of moving to a new cut path cannot be ignored.
Speed control placement (versus Hawk) - The need to adjust speed requires far less movement with the Ex than the Hawk.
Tilting Blade vs Tilting Table. Superior control and immediate comfort level with level-table-tilted-blade design cannot be ignored. It just feels right.
The Cons:
The Ex dust collection design is a joke. It traps small dropouts and works against top feeding. The Hawk, on the other hand, has no dust collection provision.....
The stand footprint is too big (versus the Hawk,) The side-to-side footprint of the Ex-21 stand seems excessive (8-10" more than the Hawk 26). The stability of the saw does not require the wide, side-to-side footprint. I am working out of a shop where floor space is limited so this matters to me but this will not be a factor for folks with no floor space issues.
The Verdict (Steeped heavily in personal opinion) :
In My Humble Opinion - the Ex deserves its position among the top rankings of available scroll saws. I hope General is able to secure a new factory and that they are able to successfully navigate the rocks and shoals of quality control vs Asian mfg. Prior to retirement, I spent 16 years sourcing out of Asia and fully understand the risk/challenge/complexity facing General as they attempt to bring a new factory online. There are a number of General employees who are raking in more frequent flyer miles than they ever thought possible.
All in all, I will put my Hawk 26 up for sale without any regrets. I do wish the Ex had the cast-iron table the New Jet features but that is minor compared to the other features that fit my personal preferences so well.
I know of one other New-in-Box Ex-21 located in Northern California (Redding area). If you are looking send me a PM.
Bruce