I can't say which is better but the question might be which is worse. I just went through the selection process knowing that I wanted a saw that I would enjoy using. If you get one that the blade change is a major production or if the vibration will shake your teeth out then you can be pretty sure that you will never use it. Do a nation wide search on craigslist for scroll saws and you will come up with hundreds of scroll saws. The problem is that they will all be starter saws. Saws like Craftsman, Reilant, Harbor Freight, AMT etc. The reason is I'm guessing is the after a couple of uses the owners give up on them. I was in the same boat with a Delta that I had. I'm very happy with the new saw that I ended up buying. I'm only a beginner but I want the problems that I encounter to be because of my lack of skill rather than because my saw will never cut right.