Ray:
The 2 examples that Scott showed at the beginning of this post are 2 separate pieces
They do not go together - The star one is a partial cutting, It's missing the star that is cut
into puzzle pieces - The shape for both just happens to be the same, this is what is throwing you off
BUT:
If you do manage to fit the pieces from the top one into the star, make sure you keep the solution
it will surely be a one of kind
So what you and Jim did is the actual pattern for the top photo
Thanks
Fab4