Opinion needed

[Around the corner]

Need popular opinion of this from the group. My wifes sister is having a 50 yr wedding anniversay this spring so I made a plaque I should say two cause I liked both of the patterns I made. One is mine the other is from Sue Mae patterns.I think I know which one but like to see what others think.The hearts are from Sue Mae and the square one is my idea.. 

[meflick]

Well, I like them both but the real question is not what the popular opinion of this group is but instead, which one do you think your sister-in-law and her hubby will like best? But, I am also assuming that you are giving them both since they are personalized. I have studied them both several times now and can't tell you I like one over the other honestly.  The square one is more of a "traditional" look - the hearts more eclectic.

[MTCowpoke22]

My preference was the square one. Was easier for me to read it. But both look great.

[edward]

Both look great, the couples pictures show better in the second one.  edward

[rjR]

As according to my wife; I have no taste, I still like the squared one better.  So if you take her opinion the first is probably nicer.

 

Both are a fantastic job on cutting though!

[Lucky2]

Damian, both pieces look great, but, I like the square one more than the heart one.

Len

[amazingkevin]

Need popular opinion of this from the group. My wifes sister is having a 50 yr wedding anniversay this spring so I made a plaque I should say two cause I liked both of the patterns I made. One is mine the other is from Sue Mae patterns.I think I know which one but like to see what others think.The hearts are from Sue Mae and the square one is my idea.. 

I'm for the square one !

[Around the corner]

Well your all thinking what I was. I chose the square one too but having you all agree with my thoughts make it easy to choose. The round one will not go to waste I will take the pictures out cut the dates off and reuse for my brothers 50th coming in a couple of years.Thanks all for your opinions Im glad your being honest , that's what I like about this site it's better than family and not scared to give people honest remarks which helps a scroller always do better. Thanks very much. Damian

[JimErn]

If I can change two things, I like the hearts.  ( I would drop the names across the top - too hard to read and they know who they are, and if possible put (not a cutting) an actual pic of them when they got married in the left heart, and a pic of them today in the right.

 

Other wise I like the square one

 

edit:  My friends have learned not to ask my opinion, sorry if I overstepped.

Jim

Edited December 3, 2016 by JimErn

[lawson56]

I have a Favorite,But since they are personalized,I assume they will be getting both.They are both Awesome   I like the Square one.

[DWSUDEKUM]

Both are really great however I tend to like the Square one a little better.

 

DW

[Dave Monk]

I like the square one also. dave

[DukeNukem]

You did a great job on both but I'm not gonna pick just one that I'm going to leave up to you sorry. Jerry

[wombatie]

They are both great but my vote goes to the square one, it was easier to read.

 

Marg 

[Be_O_Be]

 +1 on the square.

[GPscroller]

I too like the square one.  But I really like the idea that JimErn suggested.  Thanks for the pics.  Really nice design on the first plaque.

 

Jeff

[hawkeye10]

Melanie I like the second one the best and I think they will to.

[Rockytime]

I like both designs, they are well executed. However, all caps are a no no in my opinion.

[Rockytime]

ERROR! I need to amend my previous post. My reaction to all caps should have been limited to script and fancy fonts. They rarely look good in all caps. Generally san serif fonts work better in all caps.