I almost never use painter tape and only use packing tape over patterns when working with hard woods (maple, cherry, ash, walnut,.....). I attach my pattern directly to the wood with 3M Super 77. I remove my pattern with mineral spirits. Since I use Danish Oil or Tung Oil finish I can remove the pattern and apply finish immediately since those products contain mineral spirits. Since I make 100's of items each year to sell this is the process that works for me. The only time I had a lift off issue with packing tape was when I attempted to use a no name brand.