Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

 Your work with a hand held fretsaw is magnificant.  I love your painting skills also.  The image is absolutely great.   However, although the grain of the backer works as you mentioned, I don't think it works for the viewers eye.  Unfinished plywood is just that, unfinished plywood, and that is all I see.  Your original concept sounds much better.  And, of course, the piece would then need a nice frame to finish it.

  

Edited by FrankEV
Posted
17 hours ago, FrankEV said:

 Your work with a hand held fretsaw is magnificant.  I love your painting skills also.  The image is absolutely great.   However, although the grain of the backer works as you mentioned, I don't think it works for the viewers eye.  Unfinished plywood is just that, unfinished plywood, and that is all I see.  Your original concept sounds much better.  And, of course, the piece would then need a nice frame to finish it.

  

I just loved the flow of the grain too much to paint it over. I did cut the shadow and put the car and the shadow on a plain background, but it just looked ... plain.

As for the frame, it would of course be nice to have one, but making one is just too much hassle for me. I don't have any power tools except for a cheap grinder, so I have to do everything by hand. I am able to make a nice looking frame, but it would simply take too much work. 

Posted
11 hours ago, heppnerguy said:

 I can't even imagine trying to cut something like this without a scroll saw. 

I think that if you are able to do something like that with a scroll saw, you know all techniques that are required for the cutting process, so the hard pard is already done. It would just be a process of learning how to control the blade properly when using a handheld fretsaw, i.e. which speed to use in various situations and how to move and rotate the board around with just one hand. Plus you can also turn the saw around a bit, which helps cutting corners and curves.

I'd say that someone who is a good scroller would be able to use a handheld fretsaw. It would definitely take some time and much practising to get to the same level, but if someone who had zero woodworking experience (that's me!) can do it...

Posted
8 hours ago, yamatetsu said:

I think that if you are able to do something like that with a scroll saw, you know all techniques that are required for the cutting process, so the hard pard is already done. It would just be a process of learning how to control the blade properly when using a handheld fretsaw, i.e. which speed to use in various situations and how to move and rotate the board around with just one hand. Plus you can also turn the saw around a bit, which helps cutting corners and curves.

I'd say that someone who is a good scroller would be able to use a handheld fretsaw. It would definitely take some time and much practising to get to the same level, but if someone who had zero woodworking experience (that's me!) can do it...

I have to say, I have a lot of respect for you and your using a hand  powered  saw.  I guess it is a little bit like most scrollers give up on  first of second try with a spiral blade but with a little time spent with a spiral, it becomes a go to blade in a lot of cases. So not  giving up and taking time to learn to use a hand powered scroll saw all depends on how much one wishes to learn to use one. That is what I get from what you are telling me and I can testify the same with using a spiral. I still respect you as 'over the top' scroller.

Dick

heppnerguy

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Sign Up Today!

    Sign in to experience everything SSV has to offer:

    • Forums
    • User Galleries
    • Member Blogs
    • Pattern Library with 4,300+ Free Scroll Saw Patterns!
    • Scroll Saw resources and reviews.
    • Pattern & Supplier Directories
    • and More!

  • Trending

×
×
  • Create New...