You are right, sometimes it is hard to tell the depth and dimension from a flat photo. I could tell you had done some sanding and shaping and as I said, it looks good. My main intent was simply to encourage you to keep looking at ways to increase your depth and dimension of projects so that they look realistic not just a simple cut out of different pieces of wood like a flat puzzle that some people do. You don’t necessarily need to round edges more, sometimes rounding edges doesn’t make it look realistic.
I hope neither you nor Paul @Scrappile thought I was being critical of your work. That was never my intent. I was simple hoping to give you helpful tips and information that would help you as you continue to work to improve your skills in this area. I am far from an expert, having only been doing Intarsia work for a short period myself but have had the opportunity to take classes with Judy Roberts, one of the preiminent Intarsia artists. She teaches to use sanding shims to sand multiple pieces together to help give them correct shape and dimension and to use raising shims to add some depth when needed. As Dick noted, usually those are not very thick pieces but just enough to add a little more depth like on a nose for example. Brian has been doing beautiful Intarsia work for years now, and had shared his tutorial info. that uses some of the same techniques so I thought it would be helpful to see how he did it to understand what I was suggesting. This is an area that most beginners struggle with, I know I do still. So I was simply hoping to give you that information to help you as you continue to progress. You are doing fine. The key is to do what you are comfortable with as it is your project. You are the one seeing it in person and can decide what you like. We all have different visions, and ideas. Nobody’s is right or wrong or better then someone else’s. That is the beauty of art. Make it your own.Keep working at it, as I said, you are doing fine.
is the Mama and. Baby Giraffe pattern Judy’s pattern? If so, I have done that pattern (well almost - it was her Advanced class pattern last Spring - we didn’t get done in class and I need to finish it. ) it does use a lot of sanding shims and raising shims and lots of sanding for depth and dimension (you take it to class all cut out and spend 3 full days working on the sanding and shaping and you still aren’t done when you leave. ) if thst is it, I will try to share some photos of my work in progress if you want.