I did not make the pattern and I too thought the eye was not exactly what I was hoping for, but not being much of a pattern maker myself, I am always happy that others are so willing to share these with us. I happen to like wild animals of almost all kinds and this was a pattern I mainly am cutting to my grand daughter and her husband as they live where there are a lot of animals and moose are one breed that is there. My granddaughter has an entire wall dedicated to my animal work, some intarsia and some are scrolling. When I use someone else's patterns, I try to do them as close to the way they make them as possible. I did consider not making the water drops but knowing the character of this animal, I found it really was a good representation of them. I do appreciate your opinion on my work, as I do consider myself a mediocre scroller and I still strive to challenge myself and I try to listen to want others say so that I can continue to learn from others. I am like you and see things that some people cut and enjoy that really do not interest me in the least but I always try to encourage them. An example of one item I personally am not interested in is animal puzzles and simple wood toys. Once in awhile I see some of each in each of these categories that I have to admire as the work is so well done. I remember a couple of times when I ventured out and cut an item I really didn't care much about, just to have something a little different on my page where I was selling things and almost immediately received some orders for them. So, like you said, Beauty is in the eye of the beholder. Thanks for you honesty and taking the time to share it with me. I respect that you are willing to share that with me. No defense was taken by me, at all.
Dick
heppnerguy